Men who have "low" high-density lipoprotein (HDL)-cholesterol (under
40 mg/dL) are at increased risk for heart attacks. Running is one known method
for raising HDL. To determine whether men with high and low HDL-cholesterol
benefit equally from running, we examined the cholesterol changes in sedentary
men who were assigned at random to lose weight by running (46 men) or to remain
sedentary and eat normally (42 control men). This one-year study was lead by
Dr. Peter Wood and Dr. William Haskell at Stanford University.
In the runners, HDL-cholesterol increased most in men who started out with
relatively higher HDL-cholesterol and increased least in those who started out
with low HDL. Specifically, those who started with an HDL-cholesterol over 47
mg/dL had an average increase of 7.0 mg/dL after one year, whereas those who
started with an HDL under 38 mg/dL had an average increase of only 2.3 mg/dL.
Those who started with an intermediate HDL (between 38 and 47 mg/dL) had an
intermediate HDL increase (4.9 mg/dL).
The larger, more buoyant HDL particles (called HDL2) are thought to
offer more protection from heart attacks than the smaller particles (called
HDL3). The graph above shows the starting HDL-cholesterol had a
more dramatic effect on HDL2 after one year. Specifically, the
increase in HDL2-cholesterol was over five-fold greater (5.5
mg/dL) in the men who started with high HDL-cholesterol than who started with low
HDL-cholesterol (1.0 mg/dL increase). Men starting out with intermediate